Close this search box.

Dubai’s Prison Justice Method

Share Article


“It is really no various than we were in America a hundred a long time ago, right just after or all through the finish of the Victorian period,” claimed Hamden. “Even though we are seeing globalization, in the metropolis that has outlined globalization we are still observing a worth procedure that still seems to be like new Victorians” (qtd. in “They wrecked me”, 2008). Victorian period is the period from 1837 to 1901. This is how Dr. Raymond Hamden, a Lebanese-American psychiatrist who performs in the Dubai courts describes Dubai’s legal justice program. He even further explained that despite the fact that it has embraced modernization with superior increase buildings and quite rich economic climate, its felony justice process is continue to an evolving a person.

In criminal courtroom, the equivalent protection in advance of the legislation does not commonly extend to foreigners. The remarkable economic development of Dubai is wholly dependent on tens of millions of expatriates partaking actively from corporate fiscal executives down to construction and domestic careers. Emiratis, representing only 10% of the complete people are not plenty of to fulfill the demands of a “double-digit economic growth” goaded by overseas investments, so even the court docket personnel and legal professionals are foreigners.

Dubai offers of its corporate legal process as honest and protective of foreign buyers. Attorneys, having said that deny this simple fact. In Dubai, the crime of rape is termed “compelled homosexuality” as UAE law does not accept assault and rape of males. HIV and homosexuality are taboos and held in key in this bustling economic center. These, final result in rampant harassment of gays and foreigners. These identified to be homosexuals and infected with HIV are denied well being care gains, quarantined and subjected to deportation proceedings.

In accordance to a Western Diplomat who is familiar with the judicial method, equality exists only in idea, not in practice. It may have strived extremely really hard to earn a superior name in providing honest and fast inclinations of commercials promises, nevertheless, it is nonetheless struggling to balance a penal code deeply rooted in conventional Islamic and Arabic society to the destruction and prejudice of frustrating overseas people who are largely noncitizens.

In Dubai, flogging is not a practice. Usually the authorities observes the Constitutional prohibition on arbitrary arrest and detention. However, in sensitive criminal scenarios, incommunicado detention is permitted in get not to imperil the investigation. There had been problems from diplomatic missions that they ended up not notified when their citizens have been arrested and detained.

Accused can be questioned for times or even months devoid of the guidance of authorized counsel since a defendant can only avail of the providers of a lawyer immediately after law enforcement investigation has been terminated. Acquittal is based mostly on “without the need of the slightest question of guilt” In other jurisdiction, conviction is dependent on “guilt past affordable question.”

In scenarios involving killings, bails are permitted just after payment of payment identified as “blood revenue” to the family members of the sufferer. There is no formal process of bail. Momentary launch of detainees are produced only upon deposit of money or passport or through personal warranty of a human being signed in a assertion.

It can not be denied that the Felony Justice System in Dubai and other United Arab Emirates can’t or may possibly not cope up with the transforming periods. Dubai’s lawful procedure continues to be a precarious challenged when it arrives to homosexuality and lawful defense of foreigners inspite of its status as the Arab world’s perfection of modernism and riches.