Close this search box.

The Murder of New York Metropolis Police Lieutenant Joseph Petrosino

Share Article


There is no denying that New York City law enforcement Lieutenant Joseph Petrosino was a fantastic cop — focused and courageous. Nonetheless, when Petrosino was murdered in Palermo, Sicily in 1909, he manufactured some silly issues that a a lot more smart policeman may possibly never ever have created.

Joseph Petrosino was born in 1860 in Padula, Campania, in the southern suggestion of Italy, in close proximity to Naples. When he was a youthful youngster, his moms and dads despatched him to The us, alongside with a younger cousin named Antonio Puppolo, to are living with his grandfather. Quickly after Petrosino arrived in The united states, his grandfather was killed in an automobile accident. Petrosino and his cousin Puppolo were briefly sent to an orphanage. Nevertheless, the decide, emotion sorry for the two young boys, took them into his individual household, until Petrosino’s mom and dad could come to The us. Whilst ready for his mom and dad to get there in The united states (They arrived in America in 1874), Petrosino lived with a politically active Irish family members. As a consequence, Petrosino was supplied an education and learning, which built him far more possible to obtain a very good position in The usa, relatively than the other lousy Italian immigrants, who have been arriving from Italy in droves.

Mainly because of the judge’s connections, on October 19, 1883, Petrosino joined the New York City Police Department. Petrosino’s mentor was Police Inspector Alexander “Clubber” Williams. Williams took a liking to Petrosino, and Petrosino swiftly moved up in the ranks of the New York Metropolis Police Department. His promotions were being mainly the end result of Petrosino’s tough function and commitment, and also since of the reality that he was Italian, and could communicate the language. That made it probable for Petrosino to infiltrate the Italian immigrant crime factions, that had been infiltrating New York Metropolis. In 1895, Petrosino was promoted to detective, and assigned to Lessen East Aspect of Manhattan, which was populated by a massive contingent of Italian immigrants.

The brief, stocky, bull-necked, and barrel-chested Petrosino was a acquainted sight on the streets of Very little Italy. He was recognizable by his significant head and a pockmarked face that under no circumstances seem to smile. It was said that Petrosino’s toughness was enormous, and that he was not adverse to beating up criminals, just before and following he arrested them.

Petrosino very first accomplished prominence, when he investigated the notorious “Barrel Murder” of 1903. Although quite a few men had been purchased the justice for killing a man named Benedetto Madonia (then stuffing him into a barrel and leaving him on the streets), Petrosino knew the gentleman who ordered the murder was Joe Morello, the leading rating Mafia manager in New York Town. Morello’s chief henchman was Ignazio Saietta, identified on the streets as “Lupo the Wolf.” The two adult men have been feared by the Italian immigrants, and the mere mention of their name would result in Italian immigrants to make the sign of the cross in trepidation.

Equally Morello and Saietta were being notorious counterfeiters, and they utilized quite a few Italian immigrants to print up masses of two and five dollars expenditures. These denominations have been the most common tender, used more than any other denomination. Saietta owned various grocery shops in downtown Manhattan. He applied individuals grocery shops to export and import counterfeit revenue to and from Italy the expenses becoming stuffed into barrels of oil, or in crates of cheese. Whilst this counterfeiting garnered some pleasant revenue for Morello and Saietta, it did not satisfy their lust for blood. The two adult men decided to use The Black Hand extortion racket, whereby they would deliver sinister notes to Italian immigrants of some implies, threatening them with dying, if they did not shell out the cash demanded. An imprint of a “Black Band” was sinisterly placed at the base of just about every observe.

One of the Italians currently being extorted by the Black Hand was popular opera singer Enrico Caruso. Caruso, was at to start with provided an ultimatum to pay out $2000 for his security. Caruso, realizing the murderous reputation of the Black Hand, agreed to pay out that amount. Even so, right before he could pay, Caruso received a different letter now demanding $15,000. Caruso straight away took the second letter to Petrosino. Petrosino explained to Caruso to make preparations to fall the dollars off at a prearranged position. When two Italian/American gentlemen confirmed up to choose up the revenue, Petrosino arrested them on the place.

Petrosino doggedly investigated Morello and Saietta. His perseverance lastly paid out off, when in 1901, acting by an informant, he uncovered the infamous “Murder Stables” located at 304, 108th Avenue in Harlem. Petrosino ordered his adult males to dig up the stables, and they found over 60 bodies buried there. Saietta was on record as the proprietor of the stables, but he reported that he was only the landlord, and that the buried bodies with a operate of his tenants, and not his responsibility. Saietta gave Petrosino several names that were being listed as the tenants at 304, 108th Avenue. All of the surnames were Italian, but none of them could be traced to an genuine living man or woman, if they certainly existed at all.

In 1905, New York City Law enforcement Commissioner William McAdoo appointed Petrosino the head of the newly shaped “Italian Squad.” Petrosino, with 27 devoted adult males functioning less than him, was capable to thwart the Black Handers at nearly each individual flip. From 1905 to 1909, Petrosino and his squad arrested several thousand Italian criminals. Much more than 500 Italians criminals have been sent to prison, and 1000’s extra have been deported again to Italy. To show how productive Petrosino and his gentlemen have been, in 1908 by yourself, there have been 44 bombings, and 70 gentlemen arrested for those people bombings. In addition, there were being 424 Black Hand extortion issues, and 214 arrests were created as a outcome of these problems.

To include personal injury to insult, Petrosino, after he listened to that Saietta experienced been personally included in numerous black hand murder’s, confronted Saietta in Saietta’s Minor Italy grocery retail outlet. The New York Times documented, “Petrosino walked up to Lupo and reported some thing in a small voice. Then the detective’s fist shot out and Lupo fell to the floor. Petrosino, in accordance to numerous eyewitnesses, gave Lupo a severe beating.”

Saietta’s humiliation was the initial phase in the Black Hand’s elimination of Joseph Petrosino. Elevating a glass of wine, Saietta advised an affiliate concerning Petrosino, “He has ruined several. This is a consume to our good results in this article, and the hope of financial debt to him. It is a pity that it must be accomplished stealthily – that he are unable to first be made to endure as he has made so numerous many others suffer. But he guards his hide so properly that it will have to be carried out immediately.”

On February 20, 1909 New York City law enforcement Commissioner Theodore Bingham resolved to disband the Italian Squad and as an alternative build a “Secret Assistance” branch of the New York Town Law enforcement Section. Petrosino was appointed the head of the Magic formula Provider, and was specified 14 adult men, with the directive to “Crush the Black Hand and drive anarchists out of the metropolis.”

Quickly after, Law enforcement Commissioner Bingham despatched Petrosino to Palermo, Sicily, to obtain info about Italian immigrants in New York City who ought to be deported back again to Italy, mainly because of the crimes they committed even though again in their homeland. This mission by Petrosino was meant to be so secretive, that his fellow officers were being explained to Petrosino was property sick. Inexplicably, as shortly as Petrosino departed for Italy, an short article appeared in the New York Herald, announcing Petrosino’s supposedly secret trip.

Leaving his wife and three-yr-aged daughter driving, Petrosino traveled aboard the liner Duca di Genova in initial course, below the alias Simone Velletri. Petrosino carried only two yellow suitcases with him. To throw individuals off the keep track of who may possibly know of Petrosino’s intentions, the vacation spot of the ship was Genoa, Italy. On the initially two days of his voyage, not to occur in get hold of with the other travellers, Petrosino stood by itself in his room. When Petrosino last but not least appeared topside, he instructed his fellow passengers that he was going to Italy to obtain a get rid of for a digestive discomfit. But, Petrosino’s facial area was in the New York Town papers so generally, it was difficult for him not to be recognized. One man or woman who did recognize Petrosino was the ship’s purser Carlo Longobardi. Petrosino begged Longobardi not to tell any person on the ship who Petrosino genuinely was.

There was a further mysterious male aboard the ship, who created Petrosino’s acquaintance. This male named himself Francesco Delli Bovi. When the ship docked in Genoa, Delli Bovi bought off the ship with Petrosino. Delli Bovi vanished with out a trace, and it was later determined that his only function on the ship was to shadow Petrosino.

On arriving in Genoa, Petrosino took the initially teach available to Rome. In Rome, Petrosino stood at the Resort Inghilterra. On his very first early morning there, Petrosino traveled to the United States Embassy to meet Ambassador Lloyd Griscom. The objective of this conference was for Petrosino to assemble information on around 2000 Italian criminals, now residing in New York Metropolis, that Petrosino required to deported back to Italy.

Petrosino felt safe and sound in Rome, but he would not have felt so secure if he had identified that Italian-American newspaper L’Araldo Italiano had operate a tale detailing Petrosino’s Italian excursion, expressing that his final vacation spot would be Sicily. The info for this newspaper write-up could only have arrive from inside of the New York Metropolis Police Section. This story was picked up by many other newspapers, the most important of which was the New York Herald’s European edition. Petrosino last but not least recognized his intentions ended up now public, when he met two Italian-American newspapermen, whom he had regarded from New York Metropolis, in front of the Push Club on the Piazza San Silvestro. Petrosino advised the two newspaper gentlemen that his excursion was intended to be a secret, and he implored them not to tell anyone of his arrival.

The two newspaper adult men agreed, and even provided to demonstrate Petrosino the nearby web-sites of fascination. Even though he was strolling in Rome with the two newspapermen, Petrosino spotted a badly dressed person staring at him. Petrosino advised the scribes “I know that male.” But Petrosino could not bear in mind where by he experienced seen this man’s deal with right before. Petrosino followed the gentleman at a safe length to a nearby put up business office. At the put up office, Petrosino noticed the guy produce a telegram. When the man approached the counter to send out the telegram, Petrosino obtained close sufficient to hear the male say that the telegram was likely to Sicily.

Becoming suspicious that he was now getting tailed, Petrosino made the decision not to travel to Palermo right. Instead, he took a prepare to Naples. In Naples, Petrosino paid out the proprietor of a tiny ship to take him to Palermo. Petrosino arrived in Palermo on February 28, secure in the feeling that he had not been adopted.

This wrong sense of safety induced Petrosino to make various deadly blunders. Even though he took a fake title at the hotel he stood at in Palermo, Petrosino opened a lender account less than his own identify at the Banca Commerciale. Petrosino felt so relaxed that he was not being viewed, he gave his serious title to the waiters who served him at Café Oreto, where he dined nightly. Almost certainly his worst miscalculation of all was that rather of carrying his gun, he remaining it in his resort home hidden in his suitcase.

By March 7, Petrosino experienced amassed a lot more than 300 penal certificates that would make sure the deportation of numerous Italian criminals now living in New York Town. Cautious of crooked policeman in Palermo, Petrosino ultimately met with the Commissioner of Law enforcement Baldassare Ceola on March 6. Ceola mentioned later on that he was not amazed with Petrosino’s competence. In a letter to the prefect of Palermo, Ceola explained, “I observed at at the time that Lieutenant Petrosino, to his disadvantage, was not a gentleman of abnormal schooling.” Ceola also felt that Petrosino was also not really prudent, due to the fact when Ceola presented Petrosino the services of a bodyguard, Petrosino refused the present.

Back in New York City, Morello and Saietta had been plotting Petrosino’s demise. In New York Metropolis, Petrosino was a challenging man to destroy, because, as Saietta advised Morrelo, “Damn detective. The satan guards himself too totally. When he walks it is with a loaded revolver in his hand covered by a pocket, and two policeman with out their blue coats stroll near him eyeing everyone.”

Morello and Saietta realized that in Palermo matters would be quite distinctive. They experienced a number of friends dwelling in Palermo prepared to do dirty get the job done for them. And most importantly, Petrosino experienced very little safety from the regional law enforcement, mainly because he reused their support, thanks to his mistrust of their intentions.

Morello despatched two of his best killers, Carlo Constantino and Antonio Passananti, to Palermo to observe down Petrosino. There they met with the most feared Mafia manager in all of Italy, Don Vito Cascio Ferro. Cascio Ferro had a vendetta versus Petrosino much too, simply because in 1902 when Cascio Ferro traveled to New York Town to broaden his prison empire, he was pressured to flee again to Italy mainly because of hefty force from Petrosino.

On Friday night time, March 12, 1909, Petrosino went to have his nightly evening meal at the Café Oreto. It was raining out and Petrosino was putting on a raincoat, and carrying an umbrella. Petrosino took his normal desk, with his again to the wall, so he could see anyone approaching him. In accordance to the waiters, Petrosino was in the center of his food, when two peculiar adult men strode to his desk. These adult men spoke to Petrosino for only a few moments. Petrosino did not invite them to sit down with him, and he dismissed them with an angry wave of his hand. As quickly as the guys still left the cafe, Petrosino put 3 lire on the desk for his supper, and hurried immediately after the two men.

At 8:50 PM, Petrosino was standing in the piazza of the Garibaldi Back garden, when a few pictures rang out. When a passerby arrived a couple seconds afterwards, he uncovered Petrosino lifeless, with bullet holes in his correct shoulder, his cheek, and his throat. The throat wound had been the fatal just one. In Petrosino’s pocket was uncovered a postcard resolved to his spouse, which stated, “A kiss for you and my minor girl, who has expended a few months considerably from her daddy.”

Reports later claimed that three males were being associated in Petrosino’s murder. Beside the two men who confronted Petrosino at the Café Oreto, the third male was considered to be Don Vito Cascio Ferro himself. When questioned by the police, Cascio Ferro explained he was obtaining meal at the house at a Sicilian member of the Italian Parliament at the time of Petrosino’s dying. Having said that, there have been reviews that Cascio Ferro had slipped quietly absent during supper, very long ample to consider component in Petrosino’s murder, then slip back again to the evening meal celebration, right before any individual was the wiser.

The killing of Police Lieutenant Joseph Petrosino despatched tremors in the course of the streets of New York City. Straight away, Law enforcement Commissioner Bingham was fired, simply because of the leak inside of the law enforcement section, which led to the stories in the newspapers detailing Petrosino’s journey to Italy. It is believed that, due to the fact of Petrosino’s demise, hundreds of Italian criminals ended up not deported back again to Italy, and they continued to terrorize the streets of New York Metropolis for many years to occur.

It took three months for Petrosino’s embalmed overall body to return to New York City. The funeral mass was on April 9, at the old St. Patrick’s Cathedral on Mulberry Avenue, near Houston Street. The day had been declared a public vacation, and above 20,000 folks gathered in the streets to enjoy the hearse, carrying Petrosino’s system, journey from the church to Calvary Cemetery in Queens. The hearse was accompanied by 1000 policeman 2000 schoolchildren and uniformed associates from 60 Italian associations.

Several movies have been designed based mostly on the lifestyle of Police Lieutenant Joseph Petrosino. They included a silent film built in 1912 termed “The Adventures of Lieutenant Petrosino.” In 1960, Ernest Borgnine portrayed Petrosino in the film, “Fork out or Die.” And Lionel Stander also played Petrosino in the 1973 motion picture, “The Black Hand.”